A Fundamental Analysis of PT Mizuho Leasing Indonesia Tbk (VRNA)

A Fundamental Analysis of PT Mizuho Leasing Indonesia Tbk (VRNA) 

Fundamental analysis is the process of evaluating a company's intrinsic value by scrutinizing its financial statements, management, and market position. This approach helps investors make informed decisions about whether a stock is a sound investment. This article provides a comprehensive fundamental analysis of PT Mizuho Leasing Indonesia Tbk (VRNA), a financial services company listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange.

A Fundamental Analysis of PT Mizuho Leasing Indonesia Tbk (VRNA) 

1. Company Overview and Business Model

PT Mizuho Leasing Indonesia Tbk (VRNA), formerly known as PT Verena Multi Finance Tbk, is a financial services firm primarily engaged in investment, working capital, and multi-purpose financing. As a subsidiary of Mizuho Leasing Co. Ltd., a prominent financial institution in Japan, VRNA benefits from a strong corporate backing and access to international expertise and resources. The company's business model is centered on providing various financing services to individuals and businesses, generating income from interest and fees. Its products include finance leases, consumer financing, and corporate financing, diversifying its revenue streams.

---

2. Financial Performance and Key Ratios

To assess VRNA's financial health, it is essential to analyze its performance over a period, focusing on profitability, asset quality, and solvency.

A. Profitability

VRNA's profitability has shown a recent negative trend, which is a major concern for investors.

• Net Profit: Recent financial statements reveal a shift from a profitable year in 2023 to a net loss in 2024. The company reported a net loss of IDR 2.15 billion for the full year 2024, a significant downturn from a net profit of IDR 61.1 billion in 2023. This negative trend continued into the first quarter of 2025, with VRNA reporting a net loss of IDR 2.57 billion, compared to a profit in the same period of 2024. The company has attributed this reversal to a substantial increase in the "allowance for impairment losses," particularly within its Retail Business Unit, due to a rise in overdue receivables.

• Profitability Ratios:

  • Net Profit Margin: Given the recent losses, the company's net profit margin is in negative territory, which is a clear indicator of unprofitability.

  • Return on Equity (ROE): VRNA's ROE for 2024 was a negative -0.28%, a stark contrast to the positive 8.47% in 2023. A negative ROE shows that the company is not generating a return on its shareholder equity and is instead losing money.

B. Asset Quality and Solvency

For a financial services company, the quality of its loan portfolio and its ability to meet its obligations are paramount.

• Non-Performing Financing (NPF): VRNA's non-performing financing (NPF) ratio has fluctuated. While specific latest data shows a rise in overdue receivables, which led to increased impairment provisions, the long-term NPF ratio is a key metric to monitor. A high NPF ratio indicates a higher risk of loan defaults, which can severely impact profitability.

• Debt-to-Equity Ratio: The company's debt-to-equity ratio is high, reaching 303%. This indicates a high level of leverage, where the company is financed more by debt than by shareholder equity. While high leverage can amplify returns in good times, it also exposes the company to significant risks, including the potential for default, especially in an environment of rising interest rates.

---

3. Valuation and Market Performance

Valuation metrics help investors determine if the stock is currently trading at a fair price relative to its fundamentals.

• Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Ratio: Due to the company's recent losses, its P/E ratio is negative and therefore not a meaningful valuation tool. This, in itself, is a negative signal for investors, as it highlights the company's lack of profitability.

• Price-to-Book (P/B) Ratio: The company's P/B ratio is reported to be high, with some sources indicating it is over 1. This suggests the stock is trading at a premium to its book value. For a company with negative ROE, a high P/B ratio might indicate that the market has high expectations for a future turnaround, or it could simply be a sign of overvaluation relative to its current financial health.

• Stock Performance: VRNA's stock price has shown a decline in recent times, mirroring the company's negative financial performance. Over the past year, the stock has underperformed both the Indonesian Consumer Finance industry and the broader Indonesian market.

4. Risks and Opportunities

An investment in VRNA comes with a unique set of risks and, potentially, opportunities.

Opportunities:

• Strong Backing: Being a subsidiary of Mizuho Leasing Co. Ltd. provides VRNA with a strong foundation, access to capital, and potential for synergistic business opportunities.

• Economic Recovery: A robust recovery in the Indonesian economy and a more stable interest rate environment could improve the quality of VRNA's loan portfolio and reduce the need for large impairment provisions.

Risks:

• Declining Profitability: The most significant risk is the company's recent shift from profit to loss. If this trend continues, it will erode shareholder value and signal deeper operational issues.

• Asset Quality Concerns: The rise in overdue receivables and the subsequent increase in impairment losses highlight a major risk to the company's asset quality.

• High Leverage: The high debt-to-equity ratio makes the company vulnerable to market fluctuations and increases the cost of borrowing, which can further squeeze its profit margins.

• Competition: The Indonesian financial services sector is highly competitive, with numerous banks and non-bank financial institutions vying for market share.

Conclusion

Based on a fundamental analysis, PT Mizuho Leasing Indonesia Tbk (VRNA) appears to be a high-risk investment. The recent reversal from profitability to a net loss is a major red flag, and the company's high leverage and concerns over its asset quality add to the risk profile. While its affiliation with Mizuho Leasing Co. Ltd. provides some long-term stability, the company's current financial struggles are too significant to ignore.

For a prudent investor, the stock's recent performance and lack of profitability are strong indicators to exercise caution. The stock's valuation, while not easily calculated due to the negative earnings, appears to be at a premium to its book value, suggesting that it may be overvalued relative to its current financial state. An investment in VRNA should only be considered by those with a very high-risk tolerance who are confident in the management's ability to execute a successful turnaround strategy.