The Pros and Cons of Investing in PT Ever Shine Tex Tbk (ESTI) Stock
worldreview1989 -Investing in textile manufacturing companies in emerging markets like Indonesia, such as PT Ever Shine Tex Tbk (ESTI), presents a complex profile of opportunities and risks. ESTI, an integrated textile company listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange, has a long operating history but faces the challenging dynamics of the modern global textile industry. This article outlines the potential advantages and disadvantages an investor should consider before investing in ESTI shares.
 |
| The Pros and Cons of Investing in PT Ever Shine Tex Tbk (ESTI) Stock |
Overview of PT Ever Shine Tex Tbk (ESTI)
PT Ever Shine Tex Tbk, established in 1973, is an integrated textile manufacturer specializing in the production of Nylon 6 yarn and various fabrics, including woven and warp-knit fabrics. The company's production capacity is substantial, with a focus on accommodating customer requirements in terms of design, hand-feel, and functionality. ESTI operates in a highly competitive sector and is exposed to both domestic and international market trends.
Potential Advantages (Pros) of Investing in ESTI
1. Integrated Operations and Specialization in Nylon
ESTI operates an integrated facility for yarn and fabric production, offering a competitive edge.
Vertical Integration: Handling both yarn (Nylon 6) and fabric production (woven and knit) allows for better control over the supply chain, cost efficiency, and quality consistency.
Nylon Expertise: Specializing in Nylon 6 production provides a niche market focus. Nylon is a key material for performance wear, industrial textiles, and specialty fabrics, which may offer higher margins than basic cotton products.
Large Production Capacity: Significant capacity for both yarn (e.g., 21,000 tons of Nylon 6 per annum) and fabrics allows the company to cater to large volume orders from both domestic and international clients.
2. Recent Revenue and Profit Improvement (Turnaround Potential)
While performance has been inconsistent, recent financial data suggests a potential upward swing in profitability.
Revenue Growth: The company has shown periods of revenue increase, indicating a growing demand for its products, particularly in the aftermath of economic disruptions.
Profit Recovery: The company managed to post a significant recovery in net profit in its 2023 financial year compared to 2022. This jump, even if from a low base, can signal successful management efforts to control costs or capitalize on market demand. However, investors must check the sustainability of this profit in the latest reports.
3. Commitment to Sustainability and Innovation
ESTI has demonstrated a proactive approach to modern industry demands, specifically in innovation and sustainability.
"Green & Sustainable" Focus: Through initiatives like the TEXNOVA competition focused on "Green & Sustainable" innovations, the company signals a strategic move towards environmentally friendly textile processes and products, which are increasingly favored by global buyers and modern apparel brands.
Integrated Reporting: Issuing an Integrated Report (combining business performance with sustainability disclosures) demonstrates a commitment to transparency and good corporate governance, which can enhance investor trust.
4. Established Operating History
Being in operation since 1973 and publicly listed since 1992 provides the company with significant institutional knowledge, established customer relationships, and experience navigating various economic cycles. This longevity can be a source of stability.
Potential Disadvantages (Cons) of Investing in ESTI
1. Inconsistent and Low Profitability
Despite occasional surges, ESTI’s overall profitability profile is weak and volatile, presenting the most significant risk.
Volatile Earnings: The sharp decline in net profit in 2022 followed by a recovery in 2023 illustrates significant earnings volatility, making future performance difficult to predict.
Low Profitability Ratios: Financial analysis often points to poor profitability metrics, such as a Net Profit Margin (NPM) and Return on Equity (ROE) that are below industry standards (e.g., NPM of around 3% and ROE of around 1%). This indicates the company struggles to generate sufficient profit relative to its sales and shareholder investment.
Inconsistent EPS: The company has not consistently maintained positive Earnings Per Share (EPS) over several consecutive years, which is a key indicator of shareholder value creation.
2. Exposure to Commodity and Currency Risks
As a manufacturing and export-oriented company, ESTI is highly exposed to external market volatility.
Raw Material Price Fluctuations: The price of raw materials, particularly the inputs for Nylon 6 production and other commodities, can fluctuate wildly, directly impacting the company's cost of goods sold and pressuring profit margins.
Currency Risk: Although exports provide U.S. Dollar revenue, the company's costs are partly in Rupiah (IDR). Large movements in the USD/IDR exchange rate, or an unfavorable mismatch between USD revenues and IDR costs, can negatively affect reported earnings.
3. Intense Competition in the Global Textile Industry
The global and Indonesian textile sectors are characterized by fierce competition, particularly from major players in other Asian countries.
Pricing Pressure: This high competition puts constant downward pressure on pricing, making it difficult for ESTI to significantly increase its margins, especially for standardized products.
Market Share Challenges: Maintaining and expanding market share requires continuous investment in technology, efficiency, and marketing, which can strain the company’s limited resources.
4. Solvency and Liquidity Concerns
While one analysis suggested the company's liquidity ratio was "liquid," other solvency and activity ratios have been flagged as "poor" (below standard benchmarks).
Solvency Issues: Poor solvency ratios imply that the company may have difficulty meeting its long-term debt obligations, especially if profitability does not improve sustainably.
Activity Ratios: Weak activity ratios suggest inefficiencies in managing assets like inventory and accounts receivable, tying up working capital.
Conclusion for Potential Investors
Investing in PT Ever Shine Tex Tbk (ESTI) is a speculative opportunity. It represents a potential investment in a long-standing industry player attempting a crucial financial and strategic turnaround by focusing on its integrated operations and commitment to sustainability.
High Risk/High Reward Profile: A successful and sustained return to strong profitability would likely be rewarded by the market with a significant rise in stock price.
Cautionary Note: The historical trend of low and volatile profitability, coupled with unfavorable financial ratios and exposure to external risks, categorizes ESTI as a high-risk investment. It is only suitable for sophisticated investors with a significant risk tolerance who are willing to conduct thorough, ongoing analysis of the company's quarterly financial performance, paying close attention to the sustainability of recent profit increases and management's strategy execution.