Choosing the right investment instrument is a critical step toward achieving financial freedom. In Indonesia, two of the most popular options for conservative and moderate investors are Time Deposits (Deposito) and Mutual Funds (Reksadana).
While both are relatively accessible, they serve different purposes and offer varying levels of returns. This article provides a comprehensive comparison to help you decide which one aligns with your financial goals in 2026.
 |
| Deposits vs. Mutual Funds: Which Investment Option is More Profitable? |
1. What is a Time Deposit (Deposito)?
A Time Deposit is a banking product where you "lock" a certain amount of money for a specific period (tenor), such as 1, 3, 6, or 12 months. In exchange, the bank provides a fixed interest rate that is higher than a regular savings account.
Key Characteristics:
Guaranteed Returns: You know exactly how much interest you will earn at the end of the period.
High Security: In Indonesia, deposits are insured by the LPS (Lembaga Penjamin Simpanan) up to Rp2 billion per customer per bank, provided the interest rate does not exceed the LPS limit.
Penalties for Early Withdrawal: If you withdraw your money before the maturity date, you will typically face a penalty or lose the accrued interest.
2. What is a Mutual Fund (Reksadana)?
A Mutual Fund is an investment vehicle that pools money from many investors to be managed by a professional Investment Manager (Manajer Investasi). This capital is then invested in various assets like stocks, bonds, or money market instruments.
Types of Mutual Funds:
Money Market Mutual Funds (RDPU): Invests in short-term debt and deposits. Low risk, high liquidity.
Fixed Income Mutual Funds (RDPT): Primarily invests in government or corporate bonds. Medium risk.
Equity Mutual Funds: Invests in the stock market. High risk, but offers the highest potential for long-term growth.
3. Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Time Deposit (Deposito) | Mutual Funds (Reksadana) |
| Returns | Fixed and predictable. | Fluctuates based on market performance. |
| Taxation | 20% Final Tax on interest. | Tax-Free (not a tax object in Indonesia). |
| Liquidity | Low (locked until maturity). | High (can be sold/liquidated anytime). |
| Minimum Capital | Usually starts from Rp1,000,000 to Rp10,000,000. | Can start as low as Rp10,000. |
| Risk | Very Low (Bank default risk). | Varies (Market risk, liquidity risk). |
4. Which One is More Profitable?
To determine "profitability," we must look beyond the gross interest rate and consider Net Returns (after tax and inflation).
The Tax Advantage
In Indonesia, the 20% tax on deposit interest significantly eats into your profits. For example:
Deposito: If a bank offers 5% interest, your net return after tax is only 4%.
Reksadana Pasar Uang: If the fund grows by 5%, you keep the full 5% because mutual fund returns are not taxed.
Beating Inflation
As of early 2026, with global interest rates stabilizing, deposits often barely keep pace with inflation. Mutual Funds, particularly Equity or Fixed Income types, have a much higher probability of providing "Real Returns" (growth that exceeds the rising cost of living) over a 3-to-5-year period.
5. The Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?
Choose Deposito if:
You are extremely risk-averse and cannot tolerate seeing your balance fluctuate.
You have a specific, short-term need for the money (e.g., a wedding or house down payment in exactly 6 months).
You want the absolute peace of mind provided by LPS insurance.
Choose Mutual Funds if:
You want to maximize your returns through tax efficiency.
You prefer flexibility and might need to withdraw your funds at any time without penalties.
You have a longer time horizon (over 1 year) and want your wealth to grow faster than inflation.
Conclusion
There is no "one size fits all" answer. For many savvy investors, the best strategy is diversification. You might keep your Emergency Fund in a Money Market Mutual Fund for liquidity, while placing a portion of your stable savings in a Deposito for guaranteed security.