Fundamental Stock Analysis of hhgregg, Inc. (HGG)

 

Fundamental Stock Analysis of hhgregg, Inc. (HGG)

An article performing a fundamental analysis of hhgregg, Inc. (HGG) must primarily be a historical review, as the company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in March 2017 and subsequently moved to Chapter 7 liquidation in April 2017. This resulted in the closure of all its brick-and-mortar stores and the stock being delisted from the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE).

For investors, the fundamental analysis of HGG’s later years serves as a classic case study in retail disruption and the risks associated with investing in companies facing strong secular headwinds.

Fundamental Stock Analysis of hhgregg, Inc. (HGG)

---

1. Company Background and Business Model

hhgregg, Inc. was a multi-regional specialty retailer of consumer electronics, home appliances, and home furnishings. Founded in 1955, the company grew significantly, especially after its Initial Public Offering (IPO) in 2007, reaching over 220 stores in 19 states at its peak.

Core Business Strategy (Pre-2017 Failure):

• Focus on Appliances and High-End Electronics: Initially, HGG successfully focused on high-margin products like large-screen, high-end TVs and major appliances.

• Aggressive Expansion: The company pursued a national expansion strategy, attempting to fill the void left by other bankrupt retailers like Circuit City.

• Commission-Based Sales: HGG utilized a commission-based sales model, aiming to provide better customer service and drive higher-value sales than big-box rivals.

---

2. Deteriorating Financial Performance (2015-2017)

The final years of hhgregg saw a rapid and catastrophic deterioration of its financial health, which is the primary focus of its fundamental decline.

Metric (Fiscal Year 2016)	Value	Analysis
Revenue	US$1.96 Billion	Revenue was declining, particularly due to steep drops in consumer electronics sales.
Operating Income	US$-51.73 Million	The company was significantly unprofitable from operations.
Net Income	US$-54.88 Million	HGG reported 13 consecutive quarters of net losses leading up to its bankruptcy.
Total Assets	US$385.35 Million	Asset base was insufficient to cover liabilities and operating losses.

Liquidity Crisis

A critical sign of fundamental distress was the severe depletion of the company's liquidity:

• Debt-Free to Debt-Laden: As recently as 2015, the company was debt-free. By the end of 2016, however, cash reserves had fallen sharply, and the company had to tap into its revolving credit facility.

• Vendor Credit Loss: Following poor holiday sales in 2015, major vendors like Samsung and LG slashed or eliminated HGG's credit lines, forcing the retailer to pay for merchandise upon delivery. This dramatically increased the need for cash and severely limited its ability to maintain sufficient, quality inventory, which became a significant factor in the sales spiral.

• Same-Store Sales Plunge: The most damaging fundamental trend was the decline in comparable store sales, especially in consumer electronics, which saw a 39% drop in the quarter leading up to the bankruptcy filing.

---

3. Structural and Competitive Analysis

The failure of hhgregg was not just an operational one; it was fundamentally driven by a failure to adapt to profound changes in the retail industry landscape.

A. The Rise of E-commerce (Amazon)

The shift to online shopping for consumer electronics and even appliances commoditized products and led to significant price deflation. HGG’s traditional, high-overhead, brick-and-mortar model, with high-pressure, commission-based sales, became unable to compete with the price and convenience offered by Amazon and other online giants.

B. Big-Box Competition (Best Buy, Home Depot)

Larger rivals like Best Buy (in electronics) and Home Depot/Lowe's (in appliances) had the scale to negotiate better terms with suppliers, allowing them to undercut HGG on price. Best Buy successfully navigated the e-commerce transition (the "showrooming" effect) by implementing an effective omnichannel strategy, which HGG failed to do.

C. Failed Expansion Strategy

HGG's aggressive expansion into new markets, many of which were already saturated, resulted in a large number of unprofitable locations and significantly increased fixed costs (rent, payroll, etc.). The sheer overhead created an unsustainable financial burden that the rapidly declining revenue base could not support.

---

4. Conclusion: Investment Outcome

For investors holding the HGG stock (ticker HGG) on the NYSE:

• Delisting: HGG was delisted from the NYSE in February 2017 due to its low market capitalization and share price.

• Liquidation: The conversion from Chapter 11 (reorganization) to Chapter 7 (liquidation) in April 2017 confirmed that the business had no viable path forward.

• Stock Value: In a Chapter 7 liquidation, common shareholders are at the very bottom of the priority stack, behind secured creditors, unsecured creditors, and even vendors. The common stock of a liquidated company is typically rendered worthless.

In summary, the fundamental analysis of hhgregg (HGG) shows a company that was structurally disrupted by e-commerce and large-scale competitors, leading to a terminal financial collapse where equity holders ultimately lost their entire investment.